Well, I have a Hoop-It-All, but I don't have either of those machines. As for rating the Hoop-It-All, it is fairly good. The major drawback, in my opinion, is that it is supposed to use sticky-backed stabilizer to hold your project in place, and that can gum up your needles and stuff while you work. I've had a bit of success using tape and cut-away stabilizers, but even then, there is still the sticky mess left behind on the hoop. Hope that helps you decide what you are going to do.
Thanks for your comments. I feel that it is a lot of money to invest if it isn't marvellous. Waiting for more feed back.